top of page

Parshas Vayeitzei 5787

6 minutes ago
3 min read

בכורות נח.


"קפץ אחד מן המנויין - רוב"


Our Mishnah says, if while counting animals for מעשר בהמה, one of the counted animals jumps back into the pen and gets mixed up with all the other uncounted animals, all the animals in the pen are now exempt from רש"י .מעשר explains, we have a לימוד that מנין הראוי פוטר - an animal that has once been counted in a count that was fit to reach 10, is forever פטור from מעשר. So, when this counted animal jumps back into the pen, every subsequent animal that comes out to be counted might be this one that is פטור from מעשר. So, when we reach number 10, it really isn’t the 10th animal that is מחוייב in מעשר and we need עשירי וודאי ולא עשירי ספק, so the entire pen becomes פטור. The שם[ שיטה מקובצת] asks: as the animals come out of the pen to be counted, why don’t we apply the rule of כל דפריש מרובה פריש? The שיטה brings the רא"ש who answers: even if we apply כל דפריש מרובה פרוש, the 10th one that comes out will still be considered עשירי ספק. Because the תורה is מתיר a ספק like this in איסורין and we say the איסור is נתהפך להיתר because of ביטל ברוב. But in this case, using כל דפריש will not make the עשירי a ודאי. The דין of רוב tells us what to do, but doesn’t tell us that it is a ודאי.

    [שו"ת תנינא ס' קח] רע"א was asked: the תוספתא says, if there are 9 שרצים and 1 צפרדע (which is not מטמא) in רה"ר that are not discernible, and one falls away from the pile and someone touched it, we go בתר רוב and you touched one of the 9 שרצים and are now טמא. But if רוב doesn’t create a ודאי, then this person is only a ספק if he touched a שרץ, and ספק טומאה ברה"ר ספיקו טהור, so why is he רע"א ?טמא answers: Once we use רוב in determining other דינים regarding an issue, it is considered a ודאי. i.e. we use רוב in this case to determine מלקות for eating one of these 10 pieces. If it’s a שרץ it’s כעדשה, for the צפרדע it’s a כזית. So, once we use רוב and any piece that is פורש is a שרץ, moving forward we say it’s הוחזק (and is ודאי) a שרץ. But if we are only clarifying one ספק like by מעשר בהמה, is this one counted already or not, רוב cannot tell me it’s a עשירי ודאי. This also answers another דין. The דין is, a טרפה is פטור ממעשר. So how do I know that the animals coming out of the pen aren’t a טרפה? This is because we go בתר רוב and say majority of animals aren’t טריפות. But if רוב doesn’t create a ודאי, how do we ever have עשירי ודאי? But according to רע"א, since we already used רוב on these בהמות to say they aren’t טריפות regarding other דינים, i.e. they may be eaten, so they are now הוחזק as non-טריפות and therefore have the status of ודאי not טריפה and consequently are מחוייב במעשר on a ודאי level.

     ר' שמואל ברנבוים explains רע"א: When we go בתר רוב, after the psak we now consider the outcome a ודאי. But if we approach a ספק and need to come to a determination that is ודאי, then we can’t begin to even use the דין of רוב, because the דין of רוב may not be used if my doubt needs to be clarified to a certainty. Only once we had a previous ספק with this item and רוב was able to be used to clarify that ספק, that outcome is now considered a ודאי for all future issues with this item. But in our case of מעשר בהמה, all we are using רוב for is this one specific ספק, and for this ספק we need to determine עשירי ודאי, for

this רוב may not be used to begin with.

bottom of page