top of page

Parshas Vayeitzei 5787

6 hours ago
2 min read

Monetary, Interpersonal Laws and Din Torah (83)

Paying for Damage: Doing it Yourself. If a person damages another’s item and the damager is capable to do the repair work himself, the owner can refuse and tell him that he would rather receive the payment. If the owner says he would rather have the money and not fix it at all, he is entitled to do so. This is similar to the concept we mentioned previously that there is a monetary obligation to pay for fixing and not to fix or restore the item (1).

Time of Payment. All payment for damages incurred is due immediately. Sometimes a damager might want to delay payment if he knows that by waiting a few extra days, his friend will be able to do the repairs for less money. If the owner wants it fixed sooner, the damager has to oblige because he is not permitted to cause loss of usage that can affect the victim (2).

Temporary Rental. Very often, while repairs are being done, the victim has to rent a car [when it is not covered by insurance, which will be discussed separately]. Is the damager required to pay for the rental as well? This is called a grama (indirect damage) and Beis Din cannot force him to pay for it. In the Heavenly court, however, he is required to pay and it is advisable that he does so or make some monetary compromise after which each party is mochel the other. If the body shop lends a courtesy car to the victim, it needs to be determined if this is included in the cost of repairs, in which case a Beis Din cannot force the damager to pay that portion, or it is a side favor for patronage (3).

Towing Expenses. The Ketzos Hachoshen (4) explains how Chazal’s explanation of the posukim in Mishpatim yield an obligation on the damager to return a damaged item back to the domain of the victim. Thus, towing a damaged car to the house of the victim is an absolute monetary obligation on the damager. If it would make the repairwork easier by towing it straight to the body shop, it should be towed there. If it adds to the price of towing, there is a discussion among the Poskim if that is included in the damager’s obligation and a Dayan should be consulted.

(1) חזון איש ב"ק ו:ג (2) הובא בס' משפט הלכה ב:עא, בשם הגמו"ר אלישיב זצ"ל (3) פסקי המשפט עמ' תקעז (4) שעו:י

bottom of page